The Advantage of American Elite Education, Olympics and Harvard University

Published in Zaobao
(China) on 3 August 2012
by 于时语 (link to originallink to original)
Translated from by Christine.Xiao. Edited by Katya Abazajian.
In the current London Olympics, the number of gold medals for China and the U.S. is being seen by critics as an indicator of the economic competitiveness between the two countries, especially whether China can be Number One, possessing the most gold just like it did in the Beijing Olympics. No matter who is the final winner, the background of Olympic athletes has reflected the big advantage of America in elite education.

This advantage can be proved by the number of athletes coming from Harvard University. According to the Harvard campus newspaper, The Crimson, and its alumni magazine, four years ago a total of seven Harvard graduates and undergraduates participated in the Beijing Olympics; two won the gold, and one won the silver. This year in the London Olympics there are as many as nine athletes that are Harvard students. Although only one Harvard alumnus on the American swimming team went to the finals (men's 10,000 meters), at least five Harvard alumni (including one recently admitted American-born Chinese) are going to the semi-finals of the Olympic women's swimming competition. In the track and field events, many Harvard students and alumni are also among the finalists.

NBA starter, American-born Chinese Jeremy Shu-How Lin has proved that the sports star from the Ivy League university is also a straight-A student academically, absolutely not a simple-minded muscle. Comparatively, in the top two Chinese universities, Peking and Qinghua universities, the number of undergraduates is four times more that of Harvard, but in the large Chinese Olympic team, how many of them are undergraduates or graduates from these two schools?


In history, sports and body-building are part of the aristocratic education in western culture. There is a saying in the upper society of England, “The battle of Waterloo was won on the playgrounds of Eton." This tradition is passed down in American elite education. Even the origins of the name of the Ivy League are sports-related. It refers to the sports league amongst these eight universities.

Over a very long period of time, students from Ivy League universities have always been the main strength of American athletes in Olympic arena. The first world champion, James Connolly, in the first modern Olympics (1896 Athens Olympics) was studying at Harvard before the games.

It must be pointed out that the sports where American elites have strength are various aristocratic sports, especially water sports (rowing, boating, swimming), ice sports, fencing, equestrian sports, lacrosse, etc. Among nine Harvard alumni participating in this London Olympics, six are rowing athletes. In the 1964 Tokyo Olympics and 1968 Mexico Olympics, Harvard rowing team (1964 four-person rowing, 1968 eight-person rowing) represented America. In the 2008 Beijing Olympics, two gold and one silver are all from the Harvard rowing team.

American Elite Education Puts Emphasis on Sports

In figure skating, Harvard University had three Olympic champions up to 2004, 14 American champions and seven American Figure Skating Association presidents. The Chinese media's report that Michelle Kwan ever studied at Harvard University was wrong. This nine-time American figure skating champion was never recruited to Harvard University. The Ivy League universities do not admit students only for their sports talents.

The deep relationship between the Ivy League universities and the Olympics, shows that American elite education has experienced a big change from "the noble privilege” to “admission, given talents." Sports as a basic element of education and social activities are still one important consideration of modernized universities when they select the talents with leadership potential. Today among the students admitted to Ivy League universities, the sports elite account for 10 to 20 percent. The admission rate for sports elite is two to three times above that of average applicants.

American elite education emphasizes sports education, which is not entirely a heritage of aristocratic education. Athletes are more likely to win social success due to their competitive instincts. This can be supported by evidence from psychological, physiological and social investigations. Especially at the highest level of Olympic competition, intelligence and perseverance play a very important role. These are qualities that the Ivy League universities favor.

There are numerous examples that athletes trained by Ivy League universities become leaders in society. For example, Robert Stone Jr., who served a record 27 years on Harvard University's governing board and has led the presidential search committee that selected Lawrence H. Summers, the chief financial officer of the U.S. government, to be the 27th president of Harvard University, led Harvard rowing teams in breaking the 2000-meter world record. American President Gerald Ford is two-time American champion of the all-star soccer game. He accepted the coaching jobs for football and boxing at Yale before studying at Yale law school. Robert Mathias, a two-time Olympic champion, set his world decathlon records while at Stanford University. He has now been a congressman for four years. President George Bush was the captain of the Yale baseball team, and twice went to the finals of the national collegiate baseball championship.

Another example is Bill Bradley, NBA player, who excels Jeremy Shu in both basketball skills and academics. Bradley is a member of the Olympic basketball champion team and studied at Princeton University. He attended Oxford on a Rhodes scholarship. After leaving the NBA he served as congressman for three years. In 2000, he was nominated to be a presidential candidate.
 
Ivy League universities recruit sports elites from all parts of the world. David Johnston, current governor general of Canada, was the captain of ice hockey team while at Harvard, and was the model for the ice hockey team captain in the famous novel Love Story.
 
The advantages of American elite education in the cultivation of successful social leaders are fully reflected in the Olympic Games. It is really worth the deep thoughts of Chinese educators.


奥运会、哈佛大学与美国精英教育的优势



  在当前伦敦奥运会中,美中两国的奖牌名次,尤其是中国能否重演北京奥运金牌第一地位,难免被论客看成世界经济两强竞争的一个指标。无论这一奖牌竞争最后结果如何,奥运会运动员的来源,却已经反映了美国在精英教育领域的巨大优势。

  这一优势的实证是哈佛大学代表的美国精英教育产品作为运动员参加奥运会的数目。根据哈佛大学校报“Crimson”和校友会杂志,四年前的北京奥运共有七名哈佛本科毕业生和在校生参赛,两人获得金牌,一人获得银牌。今年的伦敦奥运,参赛的哈佛毕业生和在校生多达九名。虽然美国游泳队最后只有一位哈佛校友(男子1万米),至少有五名哈佛校友(包括一名刚被录取的华裔新生)进入了奥运女子游泳选拔赛的半决赛。在田径等项目的奥运选拔赛中也出现了许多哈佛学生和校友。

  NBA华裔球星林书豪的例子已经表明:美国常春藤名校出产的体育明星,是在成绩上也过得硬的学业尖子,而绝不是“四肢发达,头脑简单”。比较一下中国的北大和清华两大顶尖名校,本科生总数超过哈佛的四倍,可是在庞大的中国奥运代表队里,可以找到多少北大和清华本科生和毕业生的身影?

  历史上,体育和健身是西方贵族教育的有机部分,英国上层社会有个传统说法:“滑铁卢战役的胜利来自(贵族子弟)伊顿公学的操场。”美国精英教育至今维持了这一传统,就连常春藤盟校(Ivy League)这一名称的起源也是体育运动,指的是这八所大学之间的校际体育联赛(League)。

  在相当长时间里,常春藤盟校的在校学生和毕业生一直是奥运赛场上的美国主力运动员。1896年雅典第一届现代奥运会上出现的第一个世界冠军康诺利(James Connolly),参赛前正在哈佛就读。

  必须指出美国精英教育的体育强项是各种“贵族运动(aristocratic sports)” ,尤其是水上运动(赛艇、划船、游泳)、冰上运动、击剑、马术运动、长曲棍球(lacrosse)等等。参加伦敦奥运的九位哈佛校友中,有六人是赛艇运动员。1964年东京奥运和1968年墨西哥奥运上,都是哈佛赛艇队(1964年是四人赛艇,1968年是八人赛艇)代表了美国。2008北京奥运上,哈佛校友的两金一银也都来自赛艇。

美国精英教育重视体育

  在花样滑冰上,光是哈佛大学到2004年为止就出过3位奥运会冠军,14位美国冠军和7位美国花样滑冰协会主席。然而中文媒体关于关颖珊就读哈佛的广泛报道是错误的,哈佛大学没有招收过这位九届美国花样滑冰冠军,也可见常春藤名校并不专凭体育成就招生。

常春藤大学与奥运会的深刻关系,表明美国的精英教育虽然在上一世纪中经历了从“世家特权”到“凭才取人”的巨大演变,体育作为教育和社会活动的一个基本成分,仍然是名牌大学选择未来领袖人才的重要考虑。今天常春藤名校的录取生总体里面,体育尖子的比例大约占了一到二成,体育尖子生的录取率可以超过一般申请人的两三倍以上。

  美国精英教育重视体育,并不全是贵族教育的遗留。运动员因其竞争本能而可以获得更多的社会成功,在心理学、生理学和社会调查上都有确实证据。特别是体育运动到了像奥运这样的高层次竞争,智力和毅力的作用也非常重要,这都是常春藤名校看好的素质。

  常春藤培养的体育尖子成为社会领袖的例子不胜枚举。例如担任校董27年、主持招聘克林顿政府财长萨默斯出任哈佛大学第27任校长的小罗伯特·斯通(Robert Stone Jr.),就曾于1947年率领哈佛赛艇队打破了2000米世界纪录;福特总统是两次赢得全美大学冠军的美式足球(橄榄球)明星,在进入耶鲁法学院之前,担任过耶鲁大学美式足球和拳击教练;斯丹福大学毕业的马西亚斯(Robert Mathias),在校时就创造了十项全能世界纪录,先后获得两次奥运冠军,后来连任四届联邦众议员;老布什总统是耶鲁大学棒球队队长,两次打进全国大学决赛。

  还有在球技和学业上可说都超过林书豪的NBA名人堂成员布莱德利(Bill Bradley),在普林斯顿大学时就是1964年奥运篮球冠军队队员,本科毕业时荣获罗兹奖学金留学牛津大学。从NBA退役后连任三届联邦参议员,还在2000年问鼎过总统提名。

  常春藤名校并且面向世界招收体育尖子。现任加拿大总督约翰斯顿(David Johnston)就读哈佛大学时担任冰球队长,是著名小说《爱情故事》里的哈佛冰球队长的原型。

  奥运会反映的美国精英教育在培养社会领袖方面的成功优势,值得中国教育界深思。
This post appeared on the front page as a direct link to the original article with the above link .

Hot this week

Poland: Calm in Iran Doesn’t Mean Peace Yet

Colombia: The Horsemen of the New Cold War

China: US Chip Restrictions Backfiring

Australia: Could Donald Trump’s Power Struggle with Federal Reserve Create Next Financial Crisis?

Australia: Australia Is Far from Its Own Zohran Mamdani Moment. Here’s Why

Topics

Israel: In Washington, Netanyahu Must Prioritize Bringing Home Hostages before Iran

Ukraine: Why Washington Failed To End the Russian Ukrainian War

United Kingdom: Trump Is Angry with a World That Won’t Give Him Easy Deals

Nigeria: The Global Fallout of Trump’s Travel Bans

Australia: Donald Trump Just Won the Fight To Remake America in 3 Big Ways

Colombia: The Horsemen of the New Cold War

Australia: Australia Is Far from Its Own Zohran Mamdani Moment. Here’s Why

Canada: How Ottawa Gift-Wrapped our Dairy Sector for Trump

Related Articles

China: US Chip Restrictions Backfiring

Thailand: US-China Trade Truce Didn’t Solve Rare Earths Riddle

Taiwan: Taiwan Issue Will Be Harder To Bypass during Future US-China Negotiations

Hong Kong: Amid US Democracy’s Moral Unraveling, Hong Kong’s Role in the Soft Power Struggle

Russia: Trump Is Shielding America*