Even Biden Thinks the Immigration System Is Broken

Published in Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung
(Germany) on 26 July 2023
by Andreas Ross (link to originallink to original)
Translated from by Mallory Matsumoto. Edited by Laurence Bouvard.
Democrats and Republicans have significantly converged when it comes to immigration policy. But they would never admit it.

When federal Judge Jon Tigar first struck down a new asylum policy out of Washington, most Americans knew who their hero was and who their villain was in the affair. Then-President Donald Trump had ordered that applications for asylum could only be submitted at official border crossings and that those who had entered the country illegally could not submit them. Some hated Trump for it, others hated the judge.

Trump dismissed him as an “Obama judge” and was reprimanded for his comment by the (conservative) Chief Justice of the Supreme Court John Roberts, who said that America’s courts are independent.

Millions of Abuses

As if to prove the point, Tigar has now taken on Trump’s successor, Joe Biden. The Democrat is also trying to stop illegal border crossings.

In this attempt, Trump’s approach has been refined. Now, a person can apply for asylum at the border using an app, but must wait for months for the appointment. Also, applicants have to prove that they have already applied unsuccessfully for asylum in another country — except that there is hardly a functioning asylum system in Central America.

In addition, Biden has introduced quotas for immigrants from certain countries. In the end, though, even he believes that the old immigration system is broken because it has been abused millions of times.

That makes it all the more tragic that Republicans and Democrats will never admit how much they have converged on this issue. If Congress would pass new asylum legislation, less would depend on judges.


Auch Biden hält das Asylrecht für untauglich

Demokraten und Republikaner haben sich in der Migrationspolitik deutlich angenähert. Aber das würden sie nie zugeben.

Als Bundesrichter Jon Tigar 2018 schon einmal eine neue Asylpolitik aus Washington verwarf, wussten die meisten Amerikaner, wer in dem Stück ihr Held und wer ihr Schurke war. Der damalige Präsident Trump hatte verfügt, dass Asylanträge nur noch an offiziellen Grenzübergängen gestellt werden konnten; illegal eingewanderte Personen durften das nicht. Die einen hassten Trump dafür, die anderen den Richter.
Ihn beschimpfte Trump als „Obama-Richter“ und wurde dafür vom (konservativen) Obersten Richter John Roberts zurechtgewiesen: Amerikas Justiz sei unabhängig.
Millionenfacher Missbrauch
Wie zum Beweis dafür, hat sich Tigar diesmal mit Trumps Nachfolger Biden angelegt. Auch der Demokrat will illegale Grenzübertritte verhindern.
Trumps Ansatz wurde verfeinert: Man kann sich nun per App für ein Asylgesuch an der Grenze anmelden – muss darauf aber viele Monate warten. Außerdem müssen Bewerber nachweisen, in einem anderen Land vergeblich Schutz beantragt zu haben – aber in Zentralamerika gibt es kaum ein funktionierendes Asylsystem.
Biden hat zudem Kontingente für Migranten aus bestimmten Ländern eingeführt. Letztlich glaubt aber auch er, dass das alte Asylrecht wegen millionenfachen Missbrauchs nicht mehr taugt.
Umso tragischer, dass Republikaner und Demokraten nie zugeben würden, wie sehr sie sich da angenähert haben. Beschlösse der Kongress ein neues Asylrecht, hinge nicht mehr so viel von Richtern ab.
This post appeared on the front page as a direct link to the original article with the above link .

Hot this week

Germany: Resistance to Trump’s Violence Is Justified

Cuba: Summit between Wars and Other Disruptions

Germany: LA Protests: Why Are So Many Mexican Flags Flying in the US?

Switzerland: Trump’s Military Contingent in Los Angeles Is Disproportionate and Dangerous

   

Venezuela: The Devil in Los Angeles

Topics

Russia: Will the US Intervene in an Iran-Israel Conflict? Political Analyst Weighs the Odds*

Cuba: Summit between Wars and Other Disruptions

Germany: Resistance to Trump’s Violence Is Justified

Germany: LA Protests: Why Are So Many Mexican Flags Flying in the US?

Spain: Trump-Musk: Affair, Breakup and Reconciliation?

Switzerland: Trump’s Military Contingent in Los Angeles Is Disproportionate and Dangerous

   

Germany: If You’re Not for Him, You Should Be Afraid*

Austria: Trump Is Playing with Fire. Does He Want the Whole House To Go up in Flames?

Related Articles

Germany: Resistance to Trump’s Violence Is Justified

Germany: LA Protests: Why Are So Many Mexican Flags Flying in the US?

Spain: Trump-Musk: Affair, Breakup and Reconciliation?

Germany: If You’re Not for Him, You Should Be Afraid*

Austria: Trump Is Playing with Fire. Does He Want the Whole House To Go up in Flames?