What the Media Has Learned from Trump’s Presidency

Published in UDN
(Taiwan) on 1 January 2021
by Heng Su (link to originallink to original)
Translated from by Jaime Cantwell. Edited by Patricia Simoni.
Fox News, which once had close ties with Donald Trump, has now become bad news in Trump's eyes, which is something no one expected.

In the last moments of the election, Fox News was one of the first to announce Trump's loss in Arizona. After the election, Trump's "friend" and Fox reporter Geraldo Rivera publicly asked him to leave with "grace and dignity."

When Trump used a live broadcast to discuss the election scandal, the Fox anchor unexpectedly said, "I can't in good countenance continue showing you this," and directly cut off the broadcast, angering Trump. Recently, Trump has scolded Fox News on Twitter saying they have done a series of unforgivable things, also saying that, "I can no longer watch Fox News. I can't believe that they can do so badly!"*

For many years, Fox News and Trump have always come hand in hand. Fox has even been ridiculed by other media in the past four years as having been "a big scam created by both Trump and the media." Trump will leave office and the media will welcome the Biden era. Will the ratings of Trump-addicted media crash? How will they respond to the situation?

Eight days before Trump announced his campaign as the Republican presidential candidate in 2015, he met with senior officials from Fox News to discuss how to organize his 2016 presidential campaign. In the three months before the primaries, Trump was a frequent guest on the Fox & Friends morning show and even accepted an interview invitation for three days before the election. In his first six months after taking office, he posted 185 tweets mentioning Fox, which helped Fox to grow in popularity.

After four years, the lying politician finally showed his true face. CNN reporter Brian Stelter who wrote the book, Hoax, stated that Trump said in private that he can counter the rules of the media game and scare reporters into a frenzy. He posts Tweets every day, leading to 24 hours of constant issues and controversy, and creating a Trumpist version of reality.

However, the media believes that this is not only Trump's problem. The American political party structure and the desires of the TV entertainment market are both accomplices.

Although Trump is good at creating controversy, he is often misled by the right-wing media around him. For example, his constant insistence that the election was fraudulent was an illusive drama supported by both Trump and the right-wing media.

Newsmax has recently experienced a surge in viewership because of the wave of Trump supporters changing media platforms, along with the recruitment of former White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer, who stepped down due to a controversy, and former Fox White House reporter, Megyn Kelly, thus attracting many Trump supporters.

Recently, Newsmax expanded its newsroom to the United Kingdom and prepared to welcome a new audience; however, their good ratings only lasted for a couple of days before dropping again.

Statistics show that 40% of Republican voters watch mainly Fox News. Fox and Trump's conservative remarks and intentional creation of controversies not only increased voter turnout in the Republican Party's two elections, but also made voters highly politicized and attentive to social disputes. Most of them believe that only Trump cares about their silent voices.

The more Trump lies, the more powerful the media that supports Trump becomes. This has been called the "war on the press" by academics, but executive editor Marty Baron of The Washington Post has said, "We're not at war with the administration, we're at work."

Chairman of Fox Corporation Rupert Murdoch and his son Lachlan Murdoch also recognized the reality and gradually began recruiting Pulitzer Prize-winning reporters and producers before the election. They stated that as part of the mainstream media, Fox will undergo transformation and reorganization to restore objective news and become a better opponent. It will also protect the market of speech and help conservative voices be heard.

Fox News recently lost one-fifth of its viewers, its ratings have been surpassed by CNN, and it even suffered a small loss to the conservative internet media Newsmax. The cost of restoring objective news has been considerable, but executives say that this was expected. They estimated that the advertising and subscription fees can be offset, and their news still needs to return to the objective truth. Chris Wallace, a Fox reporter who has won awards for excellent journalism, has said that Fox can no longer be the puppet or mouthpiece for the Republican Party, and should return to truthful professional news and take the role of referee.

The choosing of sides by the media has caused society to become more divided, which is a misfortune in American history. The media's blind faith in Trump and desire for viewer ratings have caused them to turn a blind eye to climate change, racial discrimination, immigration, inadequate health care and severe economic inequality. This has disappointed many journalists, but many in the media have not yet been awakened.

Trump will leave, but populist Trumpism will not disappear. Just like a released genie, it will be hard to put back into the bottle. There are many people waiting to receive Trump's political assets. When he appears, will the media that has been unable to resist temptation? No one knows now.

The author is an adjunct professor at National Chengchi University College of Communication.

*Editor’s note: Although accurately translated, this quoted passage could not be independently verified.


和川普最麻吉的福斯新聞,竟成為川普口中的「爛新聞」,真是世事難料。

選舉最後關頭,福斯是最早宣布川普失去亞利桑那州的媒體之一;選後川普「朋友」福斯記者里維拉公開要他「優雅和尊嚴」地離職。川普利用直播大談選舉醜聞時,沒想到福斯主播說,「我不能繼續這個連線」,直接斷訊,讓川普勃然大怒。最近,川普在推特大罵福斯做了一連串不可原諒的事,「不能再看福斯新聞,真不敢相信福斯怎麼做得這麼糟? 」

多年來,福斯新聞和川普一直你儂我儂。甚至被其他媒體譏為這四年是川普和媒體「共創的大騙局」。川普即將下台,媒體將迎接拜登時代,已對川普上癮的媒體,收視率會不會崩盤?如何因應變局?

二○一五年川普宣布角逐共和黨總統候選人前八天,和福斯高層碰面,商討如何布局一六年總統大選。初選前三個月,川普是晨間節目「福斯和朋友」常客,甚至參選前三天還接受專訪。他一上任,半年內曾發一百八十五則推文提到福斯,幫助福斯新聞一路長紅。

四年下來,一個浮誇說謊成性的政治人物,終於露出「真面目」。撰寫「騙局」(Hoax)一書CNN記者Stelter指出,川普私下曾說,他能反制媒體遊戲規則,把記者唬得團團轉;他每天發推特,主導廿四小時的議題設定和爭議,更創造「川普奇觀」。

不過媒體界認為,這不全是川普的問題,美國政黨政治結構,和電視市場娛樂經濟的重口味,才是共犯結構。

川普固然擅於製造爭議,但也常被周遭右翼媒體誤導,像始終堅稱選舉舞弊,就是右翼媒體和川普相互加持的魔幻劇。

新崛起Newsmax,因失落的川粉大量轉台,加上Newsmax延攬因爭議下台白宮前新聞秘書Spicer、福斯前白宮記者凱利,吸引不少川粉。

最近Newsmax也在美國英國擴編新聞室,準備迎接新局。不過好收視只維持兩天,又往下掉。

統計顯示,共和黨四成選民主要看福斯新聞;福斯和川普保守言論,故意製造爭議,不但提高共和黨兩次選舉投票率,更讓選民高度政治化,注意社會爭端,但大多認為川普才關心他們沉默的心聲。

但川普愈說謊,鞭策川普的媒體也愈強悍,被學界稱「媒體對抗運動」,不過華郵總編輯說「我們不是搞對抗,而是信守事實第一的原則」。

福斯老闆、老梅鐸兒子也認清現實,選前逐步網羅普立茲得獎記者和製作人。他說作為主流媒體,會進行轉型改組,恢復客觀新聞,做更好的反對者。但也會守住言論市場,幫保守主義持續發聲。

福斯新聞近期流失五分之一觀眾,收視被CNN追上,甚至一度小輸網路保守媒體Newsmax,恢復客觀新聞的代價不小。但高層說,這在意料之中,他們估計廣告和訂閱費足可彌補,新聞還是要回歸客觀真實。曾獲傑出新聞獎的福斯重量級記者華萊斯說,福斯不能再做傀儡或共和黨喉舌,應該回歸真實專業新聞,做好監督裁判的角色。

媒體選邊站,造成社會更分裂,是美國歷史的不幸。媒體迷信川普和收視率的魔術,對於原來存在的氣候變遷、種族歧視、移民、醫療保健不足、貧富落差等危機反而視而不見,這讓許多優秀記者相當失落,但有許多媒體沒被喚醒。

川普會離開,但民粹川普主義不會消失。就像被釋放的精靈,很難再關回瓶子裡。等待接收川普政治資產的人不會少。當他出現,抗拒不了誘惑的媒體亂象會不會再出現?現在沒人知道。

(作者為政大傳播學院兼任教授)
This post appeared on the front page as a direct link to the original article with the above link .

Hot this week

Japan: US President and the Federal Reserve Board: Harmonious Dialogue To Support the Dollar

Austria: The EU Must Recognize That a Tariff Deal with Trump Is Hardly Worth Anything

Germany: The Tariffs Have Side Effects — For the US Too*

Thailand: Appeasing China Won’t Help Counter Trump

Peru: Blockade ‘For Now’

Topics

Peru: Blockade ‘For Now’

Japan: US President and the Federal Reserve Board: Harmonious Dialogue To Support the Dollar

Austria: The EU Must Recognize That a Tariff Deal with Trump Is Hardly Worth Anything

Mexico: The Network of Intellectuals and Artists in Defense of Venezuela and President Nicholás Maduro

Hong Kong: Cordial Cross-Strait Relations Will Spare Taiwan Trump’s Demands, Says Paul Kuoboug Chang

Germany: The Tariffs Have Side Effects — For the US Too*

Ireland: We Must Stand Up to Trump on Climate. The Alternative Is Too Bleak To Contemplate

Canada: Carney Takes Us Backward with Americans on Trade

Related Articles

Peru: Blockade ‘For Now’

Japan: US President and the Federal Reserve Board: Harmonious Dialogue To Support the Dollar

Germany: The Tariffs Have Side Effects — For the US Too*

Ireland: We Must Stand Up to Trump on Climate. The Alternative Is Too Bleak To Contemplate

Canada: Carney Takes Us Backward with Americans on Trade