Asylum in Germany for Snowden? – Limited Liability

Published in General-Anzeiger Bonn
(Germany) on 3 July 2013
by Thomas Wittke (link to originallink to original)
Translated from by Sean Thacker. Edited by Robert O'Connor.
A look into the Basic Law might be helpful. Article 16 says, “Persons persecuted on political grounds shall have the right of asylum.” The constitution then goes on to specify some conditions.

But the core statement remains. So the courts will check his activities — that is, if Snowden is actually serious about his German asylum application. Doubts about that are permitted.

Despite all the criticism of the conditions in America and the systematic devaluation of human rights driven by the U.S., for example in Guantanamo Bay prison, President Barack Obama is not really heading a dictatorship. In America there are plebiscites and local referendums.

But one thing is also sure: The U.S. is no longer a perfect democracy. The attacks of Sept. 11, 2001 are no excuse for spy actions of epoch proportions. At least in a moral sense, Snowden did the right thing. The problem is that Washington’s arm is too long.

Regardless of which country takes him in, he must constantly protect himself from attacks by U.S. intelligence agencies. Polls within the U.S. are asking the government in Washington if it might put an end to Snowden’s activities, with violence if necessary.

The debate that has flared up in Berlin as to whether or not the “whistleblower” can seek asylum in Germany is heavily colored by the election campaign. The fact remains that in Germany, courts decide how the constitution is interpreted. They do not offer complete protection.


A look into the Basic Law might be helpful. Article 16 says, “Persons persecuted on political grounds shall have the right of asylum.” The Constitution then goes on to specify some conditions.

But the core statement remains. So the courts will check his activities—that is, if Snowden is actually serious about his German asylum application. Doubts about that are permitted.

Because despite all the criticism of the conditions in America and the systematic devaluation of human rights driven by the U.S., for example in Guantanamo Bay Prison, President Barack Obama is not really heading a dictatorship. In America there are plebiscites and local referendums.

But one thing is also sure: The U.S. is no longer a perfect democracy. The attacks of September 11, 2001 are no excuse for spy actions of epic proportions. In a moral sense, at least, Snowden did the right thing. The problem is that Washington’s arm is too long.

Regardless of which country takes him in, he must constantly protect himself from attacks by U.S. intelligence agencies. Polls within the U.S. are asking if the government in Washington might put an end to Snowden’s activities, with violence if necessary.

The debate that has flared up in Berlin as to whether or not the “whistle blower” can seek asylum in Germany is heavily colored by the election campaign. The fact remains that in Germany, courts decide how the Constitution is interpreted. They do not offer complete protection.
This post appeared on the front page as a direct link to the original article with the above link .

Hot this week

Canada: It’s Not Worth a Trade War To Save Ontario’s Foreign-Owned Car Plants

Australia: Trump Suggests He Would Not Help UK in Another Falklands Clash

Mexico: Bessent’s Futile Sanctions Crumble in the Face of the Shanghai Group’s Multipolar World Order

Canada: Carney Must Be Honest about the Cost of Counter-Tariffs

Topics

United States of America: North Korea, China and Taiwan: What Game Is Trump Playing?

Austria: Trump Is Holding the Iranian People Responsible for His Failure

Mexico: Bessent’s Futile Sanctions Crumble in the Face of the Shanghai Group’s Multipolar World Order

Spain: To the Barricades

Nigeria: Who Will Give Donald Trump His Desperately Needed Victory? Nigeria Should Be Asking That

Canada: Carney Must Be Honest about the Cost of Counter-Tariffs

Related Articles

Guatemala: The Return of Nationalism

Germany: Trump’s Fatal Signal to Putin*

Austria: Trump Punishes Merz but Also Weakens His Own Country

South Korea: Trump’s Move To Cut Troops in Germany Must Not Affect Korean Peninsula

Poland: Polish PM Donald Tusk Questions US Loyalty in Financial Times, Targeting Both Parties