The Democratic Party scored a decisive victory in the United States’ midterm elections, securing a majority in both the Senate and the House of Representatives. Commenting on the result Nov. 5, Ronan Tse-Min Fu, an assistant research fellow at Academia Sinica’s Institute of Political Science, Taiwan, referred to it as a “retrospective vote” to punish President Donald Trump, but said that it did not necessarily mean the American public had endorsed the Democratic Party. Inflation was a core issue in these midterms, with voters strongly associating the foreign policy issue of the U.S.-Iran war with rising oil prices; indeed, some 63% of the public considered military action against Iran to be a mistake.
On the morning of Nov. 5, Taiwan’s Institute for National Policy Research held a symposium titled “The Post-2026 U.S. Midterm Election Situation and Its Implications for Taiwan.” The opening session focused on interpreting the U.S. midterm election results and was moderated by Hung-Jen Wang, INPR director and a professor of political science at National Cheng Kung University. Also taking part in the discussion were Stanley Kao, former Taiwan representative to the United States; Roy Lee, former Taiwan deputy minister of foreign affairs; Fu, the assistant research fellow at Academia Sinica’s Institute of Political Science; and Chung-li Wu, a distinguished research fellow and director of the same institute.
According to Fu, the Democrats’ recapture of both houses of Congress amounted to “retrospective voting,” meaning the American people had chosen to punish the Republican Party based on Donald Trump’s performance in office — but that this did not represent a vote of confidence for the Democratic Party. The Republican Party’s loss of seats stemmed from voter dissatisfaction driven primarily by three factors.
First, voters clearly had a negative opinion of the administration’s performance. On Nov. 3, the average gas price across the U.S. stood at $4.15 per gallon, the highest ever recorded on an Election Day. Additionally, 65% of voters thought that tariffs had harmed the U.S. economy.
Second, the apportioning of blame was perfectly clear: This year, both the White House and Congress were under Republican control, and both the tariffs and the eight-month U.S.-Iran war were the result of Trump’s decisions. Consequently, Trump’s approval rating was a mere 38%, down from 45% at the 2018 midterm elections.
Third, the Democratic Party was considered an alternative, albeit a barely acceptable one. Forty-seven percent of voters held a favorable view of the party, versus 53% who had unfavorable views. Even though the negative views outweighed the positive, the Democrats still fared slightly better than the Republicans at 59% to 41%.
Fu noted that the Democrats winning a majority of seats despite a favorability rating of less than 50% suggested that some of their support came from voters who disliked the Republican Party. These votes therefore expressed rejection of Trump rather than support for the Democrats.
According to Fu, while inflation was a central issue, the Democrats’ advantage did not come primarily from voters prioritizing the economy, but rather from voters who were most concerned about the “state of American democracy,” namely the rule of law, checks and balances, and the proper functioning of elections. Concerns about the functioning of democratic institutions helped solidify the Democrats’ base, while rising prices meant that voters no longer generally saw the Republicans as better equipped to handle economic issues.
Fu noted that voters rarely cited the U.S.-Iran war as a primary issue, although they did link it to rising oil prices, meaning the war influenced their voting decisions through its impact on the cost of living. Only 4% of voters considered foreign policy a top issue, yet 63% saw military action against Iran as a mistake. In an interview, Trump acknowledged that it was “largely true” that the Iran war had contributed to the Republicans’ loss, but he limited the issue to a short-term rise in oil prices, insisting that voters still supported his Iran policy — a claim inconsistent with polling data.
Among voters as a whole, Fu stated, immigration enforcement had shifted from an issue that benefited the Republicans to one that worked against them. Fifty-seven percent of voters believed the Trump administration had gone too far in enforcing immigration laws, meaning the Republican Party’s edge on immigration was confined to a minority of voters for whom immigration was a primary concern.
[T]he Democrats' advantage is overwhelming. But Trump has pursued a policy of increasingly concentrating power in his own hands and circumventing both Congress and the courts.
[T]he Democrats' advantage is overwhelming. But Trump has pursued a policy of increasingly concentrating power in his own hands and circumventing both Congress and the courts.
[T]he Democrats' advantage is overwhelming. But Trump has pursued a policy of increasingly concentrating power in his own hands and circumventing both Congress and the courts.