A Necessary Demonstration of Force

Published in Lidovsky
(Czech Republic) on 18 March 2015
by Zbyněk Petráček (link to originallink to original)
Translated from by Mark Nuckols. Edited by Nicholas Eckart.
What would Albrecht von Wallenstein say about the American convoy? It’s not wrong to demonstrate force. It can only be a mistake when it’s necessary to demonstrate openness and empathy instead. But in recent years, Europe has moved away from such moments.

One can say as much of the American military convoy, which will drive through the Czech Republic at the end of March. It obviously is a demonstration of might. But anyone who doesn’t like it should say how NATO is to react to the demonstrations of Russian might that started in 2008 and have since culminated in the annexation of Crimea.

A number of Czech politicians consider the planned convoy a provocation (Filip, Communist Party of Bohemia and Moravia), a superfluous demonstration of might (Veleba, Party of Civic Rights), a needless gesture (Bartošek, Christian Democratic Union-Czech People’s Party) and saber-rattling (Berkovec, ANO). As if they didn’t know that having no force worthy of demonstration is worse than demonstrating force at a necessary moment. The Czech army, with all due respect to its deployment on expeditions, is not capable of effectively demonstrating force in Europe. If we want a small professional army and the luxury of abolishing compulsory service, let’s be glad that allies are demonstrating force on our behalf.

Many Czech politicians (not just those cited) give the impression that they’ve taken a fancy to Albrecht von Wallenstein. His Duchy of Friedland was carved out of hereditary estates from the historical land register. As a state within a state, it enjoyed privileges. It didn’t have to provide for the overwinter billeting of armies, sparing itself expenses and unpleasantness. Wallenstein wouldn’t have had to host an American convoy — but don’t buy it.

How could admirers of Wallenstein forget that it was precisely he who first maintained a standing army with contributions and his own resources? There are simply two sides to every luxury. Do we want such a luxury? Do we want an army of our own that enables us to demonstrate force — and do we have the money for it?


Co by na americký konvoj řekl Albrecht z Valdštejna? Není chybné demonstrovat sílu. Chybné to může být jen tehdy, kdy je místo síly třeba demonstrovat vstřícnost a empatii. Ale takovým chvílím se Evropa v posledních letech vzdálila.

Tolik lze říci k americkému vojenskému konvoji, který koncem března projede Českem. Demonstrace síly to pochopitelně je. Ale komu se to nelíbí, ať řekne, čím má NATO reagovat na demonstrace ruské síly, které začaly v roce 2008 a zatím vyvrcholily anexí Krymu.

Řada českých politiků pokládá chystaný konvoj za provokaci (Filip, KSČM), zbytečnou demonstraci síly (Veleba, SPO), zbytečné gesto (Bartošek, KDU-ČSL) či harašení zbraněmi (Berkovec, ANO). Jako by nevěděli, že horší než sílu v potřebné chvíli demonstrovat je sílu hodnou demonstrace nemít. Česká armáda, při vší úctě k jejímu nasazení přiexpedicích, není schopná účinně demonstrovat sílu v Evropě. Chceme-li malou profesionální armádu a luxus zrušené prezenční služby, buďme rádi, že demonstraci síly za nás dělají spojenci.

Mnozí čeští politici (nejen ti citovaní) vzbuzují dojem, že se zhlédli v Albrechtu z Valdštejna. Jeho frýdlantské vévodství bylo vyňato ze zemských desek. Jako stát ve státě požívalo privilegia. Nemuselo zajišťovat přezimování armád, čímž ušetřilo náklady i nepříjemnosti. Valdštejn by americký konvoj hostit nemusel, no nekupte to.

Ale jako by obdivovatelé Valdštejna zapomínali, že právě on jako první vydržoval stálou armádu – z kontribucí i ze svého. Holt každý luxus má dvě strany. Chceme takový luxus? Chceme armádu umožňující vlastní demonstraci síly a máme na ni peníze?
This post appeared on the front page as a direct link to the original article with the above link .

Hot this week

Egypt: Does the Trump-Xi Summit Lay the Foundations for a US-China Accommodation?

Taiwan: As Trump Recognizes CCP’s View of Resistance against Japan, Lai Government Idly Watches ROC’s Legitimacy Be Weakened

Canada: Trump Finds Gangsterism Doesn’t Always End Well

Canada: When Exactly Did Americans Decide To Normalize Crazy?

Canada: The Price of Words

Topics

Germany: America Looks Weak All Over Again

   

Taiwan: US-China AI Co-opetition* and Taiwan’s Role

Germany: Trump Is Yielding a Key Country to Iran*

Venezuela: Washington and the National Liberation Army

China: Editorial: China-US Consensus on 8 Outcomes Sends a Major Signal

Saudi Arabia: A Reading of the Trump-Xi Summit

Nigeria: California Recognizes Lagos, Will Nigeria?

Austria: Iran Gives Trump No Respite before the Midterm Elections

Related Articles

Germany: America Looks Weak All Over Again

Germany: Trump’s Threat of Violence against Allies Will Be Felt for a Long Time*

Germany: Sabotage and Attacks: War without a Declaration of War

Taiwan: US-EU Estrangement and Global Disorder

Austria: Trump May Talk a Lot of Nonsense — But NATO Restructuring Is Moving Forward Nonetheless